Thanks, Eid Mobarak I think we should celebret Eid in one day following Soudi Arab Muhammed Ashraful Karim
P.O.Box 2002
Mafikeng 2745
South Africa
Tel:0027 18 381 5293 (Work) 0027 18 381 1815 (Home) Fax:0027 18 381 5294 Mobile/Cell: 0027 737 847020 Another emailaddresses: ashraf1965@gmail.comashraful3@hotmail.com --- On Sun, 21/9/08, Iqbal Karim <iqbalkarimrashed@yahoo.com> wrote: From: Iqbal Karim <iqbalkarimrashed@yahoo.com>
Subject: Re: [greater_noakhali] Observing Holy Eid in a same day around the world
To: greater_noakhali@yahoogroups.com
Date: Sunday, 21 September, 2008, 11:59 AM
| hi all, bengoli, eid mobaruk rashedgasbariadohaq atar@yahoo. com
--- On Sun, 9/21/08, ariful Zobayer <ariful_zobayer@ yahoo.com> wrote:
From: ariful Zobayer <ariful_zobayer@ yahoo.com>
Subject: Re: [greater_noakhali] Observing Holy Eid in a same day around the world
To: greater_noakhali@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Sunday, September 21, 2008, 1:11 AM
thanks harun bai good topic keep it up
----- Original Message ---- From: Harunur Rashid <mhr_rbl@yahoo. com> To: noakhali@yahoogroup s.com; greater_noakhali@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Saturday, September 20, 2008 1:52:34 AM Subject: [greater_noakhali] Observing Holy Eid in a same day around the world | Dear all, Observing Holy Eid in a same day around the world is not correct. Our Prophet(S) said, "You do observe Eid seeing the moon". According to the Holy Al-Hadis we should observe Eid seeing the moon, but not hearing the news of appearing the new moon. It should be noted that it is not mandatory to see the new moon by all the people in a geographical area. For example in Bangladesh if a few people see the moon and if this news is spread over whole the country , then all Bangladeshis must observe the holy Eid in a same day. It is very easy to spread over the news of appearing moon from one zone to another zone in Bangladesh. But it is not very easy to reach the news of appearing moon from Saudi Arabia to Bangladesh without the satellite system. In our country some people celebrate Eid following Saudi Arabia. This is not correct. Their argument is that they can receive the news of appearing the moon in Saudi Arabia in a moment through the electronic media. So they observe the Eid following Saudi Arabia. Electronic Media is run by the satellite system. So due to any reason if whole the satellite system of the world become out of order during the time of appearing moon and continue for several days (let this is 3 days), then what would be happened ? Is this group of people will observe the Eid 3 days after of the day of Saudi Arabia? Because, this group of people will hear the news of the new moon after returning back of the satellite system's previous good condition. Isn't it? Arabic date, month and year are gone by the moon's movement and Arabic daily time is run by the sun's movement. According the sun's movement every country/zone' s has different time zone. We pray our Salat / Namaz according to the sun time. Can all the Muslims pray their Salat in a time around the world? Like this the moon appears in different countries in different times and in different days. So naturally the Muslims of different countries will observe the Eid in different days. It is clear and transparent. That group of people observes Eid in a same day as like as in Saudi Arabia, but do they can pray Eid Salat in a same time as like as in Saudi Arabia? Long ago (let 500 hundred years ago) there was neither satellite system nor airplane. Then it took many days to reach our country from Saudi Arabia. In that time how did the people of our country hear the news of appearing the new moon in Saudi Arabia? Certainly in that time the people of our country did not wait to hear the news of appearing the moon in Saudi Arabia to observe the holy Eid in our country. Islam is an ancient as well as modern religion for ever. There is no scope to reform or change any Islamic law in course of time. So we should convince the people who observe the holy Eid in our country following Saudi Arabia. May Allah give us actual understanding about Islamic Laws. Thanks to all. Allah Hafez. Harun Dhaka | | |
New Email addresses available on Yahoo! Get the Email name you've always wanted on the new @ymail and @rocketmail.
Hurry before someone else does!
__._,_.___
Deep condolence for the Sadr victims. May Almighty give the family members of victims enough strength to recover from this great loss soon. Let us extend our hand to them the way we can.
[Disclaimer: Any posting to this group is the opinion of the author himself. Authors of the messages to the Group are responsible for the accuracy of their information and the conformance of their material with applicable copyright and other laws. Many people will read your post, and it will be archived for a very long time. The act of posting indicates the subscriber's agreement to accept the adjudications of the moderator]
__,_._,___